Men Rights India

Fight against Legal Terrorism

  • Contact
  • Bare Acts
    • IPC 498A bare act
    • CrPC 125 Bare Act
    • The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – bare act
    • Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Bare Act
  • 498a
    • 498a Tips
    • 498a Info
    • 498a Judgments
  • DV Act
    • DV Act Tips
    • DV Act Info
    • DV Act Judgments
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
    • Maintenance HMA 24 Judgments
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Child Custody
    • Child Custody Visitation Judgments
    • Child Custody Visitation News
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Misc
    • Divorce Judgments
    • Law Misuse
    • Marriage
    • Misandry
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Important Posts
You are here: Home » Uncategorized » Critique and comments on Draft National Policy for Women, 2016

Critique and comments on Draft National Policy for Women, 2016

20 Jun 2016 By videv 2 Comments

Following are my comments on Draft National Policy for Women, 2016:

👉(Read Online eBook): How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act 👈

1.6 Several paradoxical trends have been observed in the past few years. The growing acknowledgement of gender rights and equality is juxtaposed against increase in reporting of various forms of violence against women such as rape, trafficking, dowry etc.;

Above conclusion is given without any statistical data, to demonstrate if increase in rape, dowry etc are much higher than population growth.

1.8 The current status of women with respect to human development parameters, legal rights for women to life and freedom from violence, economic and social discrimination and their rights to equality and equity shows that a lot still remains to be done. It is necessary therefore, to reinforce the rights-based approach for creating an enabling environment in which women can enjoy their rights.

There are existing laws like PWDVA, 2005 which protect women from domestic violence, and give them several rights like right to protection, right to residence, maintenance, compensation etc.  So rights-based laws and reliefs have been there for 10 years already now.  What studies have been done to confirm that present framework of rights-based laws for women have not been enough, and where are the gaps?

1.9 In the coming years, India is expected to gain significantly from it’s ‘demographic dividend’ as the share of it’s potential productive workforce will increase in numbers as compared to the aging population of other countries. To what extent the country can seize this dividend and benefit from it will largely depend on how women exercise their rights and entitlements and contribute to the development process.

Above is a more of an opinion than a conclusion based on any data.  Economies progress based on contribution by both men and women.

1.11 The re-scripting of women’s empowerment has been envisaged as a socially inclusive right based approach while reinforcing the rights and entitlements provided under the Constitution of India. The policy will enable sustainable socio economic, political empowerment of women to claim their rights and entitlements, control over resources and formulation of strategic choices in realisation of the principles of gender equality and justice.

A purely rights-based approach will fail if the misuse of rights-based laws like PWDVA is not stopped.  In fact, it’s probably true that those who know how to (mis)use the law better will clog the courts/infrastructure and crowd out the other victims who need safeguarding of their rights.

5. I. iv) A gender transformative health strategy which recognises women’s reproductive rights with shifts such as family planning focus from female sterilisation to male sterilisation will be developed and implemented

There needs to be details based on studies as to why this is necessary, and how the proposed alternative will be better for whole of society.

5. I. viii) The National Mental Health Policy (2014) recognises that women have a greater risk of mental disorders due to various reasons primarily due to discrimination, violence and abuse. A systematic approach to provide requisite screening, care and treatment especially at primary level will be made.

Women have higher rates of anxiety or depression, but there is no clear-cut cause that it’s primarily due to discrimination, violence and abuse, as being stated in draft policy.

See research below:

http://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2011/08/mental-illness.aspx

The authors cited previous research that found women suffer more than men from depression, because “women ruminate more frequently than men, focusing repetitively on their negative emotions and problems rather than engaging in more active problem solving.”

The findings support gender-focused prevention and treatment efforts, the study said. “In women, treatment might focus on coping and cognitive skills to help prevent rumination from developing into clinically significant depression or anxiety,” said lead author Nicholas R. Eaton, MA, of the University of Minnesota. “In men, treatment for impulsive behaviors might focus on rewarding planned actions and shaping aggressive tendencies into non-destructive behavior.”

5. II. v) Continued efforts will be made for the gender sensitization of the faculty and curriculum, content and pedagogies for an understanding of concepts of masculinity and femininity and gender stereotypes. Gender champions in schools and colleges will be promoted to ensure gender sensitivity in the educational system.

Gender sensitization cannot be a one way track where men/boys are to be taught on how to ‘behave’, and so on.  Both genders need to be taught appropriate behaviour within families, society, schools etc.  The idea of gender champions in schools/colleges is either idealistic, or probably more akin to a communist dystopia where people will be programmed by state on what are the right modes of behaviour.  There are broad influences on growing boys and girls from families, friends, society, media, movies, TV, and so on; and to imagine that an initiative like gender champion in schools/colleges can override all those influences is wishful thinking at best.

vii) Children of migrant families tend to get left out of the school system and existing schemes are not effectively coordinated or implemented. Innovative and accessible educational systems will be developed, especially in large construction sites, salt pan areas, plantations, and other manufacturing zones, which predominantly employ women labour.

Good initiatives like these need to be there for all migrant families, and not only for zones which predominantly employ women labour.

III.Economy
Poverty Women constitute majority of population affected by poverty. Efforts for assessment of the incidence of poverty by gender estimates will be done as household estimates do not provide gender poverty estimates.

It’s a superfluous and contradictory statement: if there is no data on poverty by gender, how is the conclusion made that women constitute majority of population affected by poverty?

ii) Gender wage gap across rural and urban, agricultural and non- agricultural jobs, regular and casual employment will be addressed. Ensuring pay parity, satisfactory conditions of work are critical subjects for insecurity for women particularly in the informal employment. This growing informalisation and casualization of women’s work / labour will also be adequately addressed. .

India should not fall to western feminist and media driven wage gap myth, because it is proven that there is no wage gap between genders if hours of work and other factors like overtime, odd hours of work etc are considered.  Ministry should first publish a white paper on wage studies before undertaking any addressing of the ‘issue’.

iii) Fiscal and monetary policies will be analysed from gender perspective since they have impending impact on the lives of women. The gender affirmative role of direct taxation will be further enhanced through various incentives like reduction in stamp duties for women if assets are registered in their name, lowering of income tax slabs for women etc.

Such measures acknowledge women to be perennially weaker sex, dependent, and un-empowered.  There is no need for such cosmetic and useless initiatives, because when we give women opportunities to educate, develop, and contribute to economy; giving stamp duty rebates or income tax rebates tends to tell them that they are not good enough.  Further, such measures don’t discriminate among economic classes, and it will lead to a ridiculous scenario that rich women who can easily afford to buy property, will garner a lion share of such stamp duty rebates.

v) Recognising that trade agreements are not gender neutral and that differential impact of trade policies on gender exists, especially for women working in agriculture, food processing, textiles etc., A full review of all existing trade treaties and agreements from a gender equity dimension will be made. Future negotiations should be backed by Gender Trade Impact Assessment of policy and agreements on women’s wages, health and livelihood.

It’s a very short-sighted policy statement that trade agreements are not gender (women’s gender) neutral.  A trade agreement impacting a particular sector of economy will affect people employed in that sector, and if more men are employed in that sector, then it’s the male gender which is at risk of negative impact.  Maybe the policy statement should be revised to acknowledge that trade agreements can affect both genders negatively, and then mention that scope of national women’s policy is to mitigate possible negative impact of trade agreements only on women.

vi) Women undertake the bulk of unpaid care work such as looking after and educating children, looking after older family members, caring for the sick, preparing food, cleaning, and collecting water and fuel etc. This unequal burden of unpaid care undermines women’s participation in economy.

A value judgment is being made that paid work is better than unpaid work.  This is possibly a dangerous conclusion, since for much of so called unpaid work, there is no value in terms of Rupees which can be placed, but it is highly valuable nevertheless.  E.g. a child being taken care of by mother (or close relative) can’t be compared to the child being taken care of in a day creche.  Similarly, devaluing of unpaid work can lead to negative consequences for children (and ultimately for society) if they don’t get adequate time with mothers, who are pressurized to go to paid work as soon as they can after birth of child.  There are negative costs to society if children who are not raised properly grow up to be nutritionally deficient, or have psychological issues etc.

Further measures will be undertaken to free woman’s time for paid work through time-saving technologies, infrastructure, child/parental care services (Crèches) and child care/parental leave.

Studies need to be conducted to see if there are any ill-effects of children being left in day-care/creches.  Parental leave should be for both parents.

Agriculture v) Regarding resource rights of women, efforts will be made to prioritize women in all government land redistribution, land purchase and land lease schemes to enable women to own and control land through issue of individual or joint land pattas. In the case of private land, joint registration of land with spouses or registration solely in the name of women will be encouraged along with measures such as concessions in registration fee and stamp duty etc. to incentivize land transfers to women.

Such measures should not deprive land from men who could have utilized that resource much more efficiently and productively.  Again, the point about rebates in fees and stamp duty seems dis-empowering rather than empowering.  If government thinks that higher stamp duty and fees are a deterrent to property transfers, then why shouldn’t they be reduced for everyone?

x) Wives of farmers who committed suicide on account of failure of crops or heavy indebtedness are highly vulnerable and are left behind to take care of their children and family. Special package for these women that contains comprehensive inputs of programs of various departments/Ministries like agriculture, rural development, KVIC, MWCD will be provided for alternative livelihood options.

It will be much better to focus on preventing male farmers’ suicide in the first place.

Service Sector
i) Women’s participation in the upcoming services such as information based industries, telecommunication, infrastructure, customized highly skilled business services, software- designs; computer programming and financial services (Banks and insurance) will be encouraged. Skills and work incentives for frontline workers which rely heavily on female labour in health and education will be strengthened.

ii) The service sector will encourage equal employment opportunity through jobs/enterprises for women especially in high paid jobs to post graduates and professionally qualified women.

This should be limited to creating opportunities and removing hurdles, but not venture into ideas like quotas for women employees etc.

IV. Governance and Decision Making i) Establish mechanisms to promote women’s presence in all the three branches of the government including the legislature, executive and judiciary. Women’s participation in the political arena will be ensured at all levels of local governments, state legislations and national parliament with at least 50% reservation for women in local bodies and 33% in state assemblies and parliament to provide more responsive, equitable and participatory development.

Such quota like measures can also be termed discriminatory since they will stop many qualified and meritorious men from taking up role in panchayat or as member of parliament.  There is no clear study or conclusion that forcing of gender parity will lead to more development or equitable development.

ii) Increase the participation of women in civil services, judiciary and in corporate boardrooms through appropriate modules for guidance and counselling, coaching, provision of financial incentives and quotas.

Such quota measures will reduce competitiveness of industry, and dissuade meritorious people from contributing.

Media i) Gender parity in the mass media i.e. print and electronic media, advertising world, film sector and new media will be promoted by increasing the presence of women in the decision making positions.

ii) Encourage the entry of women in media industry through promotion of journalism and mass media courses and ensuring adherence to equitable work conditions. Setting up women media centres to provide technical training and skill building will be encouraged.

One of Modi government’s mantras was: “Government has no business to be in business”.  But policy statements indicate the opposite where government wants to control private businesses including media, advertising, films, journalism etc.  Further, there are already many women in media and journalism, so it’s not clear what is the problem this policy is trying to solve?

v) To recognize special needs of single women including widows separated, divorced, never-married and deserted women. A comprehensive social protection mechanism will be designed to address their vulnerabilities, create opportunities and improve their overall conditions.

In line with feminist propaganda (though subtle), above only confirms that the WCD ministry thinks that women are always vulnerable or weak.  Some of previous policy statements about preventing violence against women mention about need to protect women from violence in marriage.  Above statement suggests that never married women are also vulnerable.  So the underlying premise is that women are always vulnerable or weak or at threat of violence – whether they chose to stay single or got married.  Maybe WCD ministry should first come up with some comprehensive and clear statement about what it considers to be ideal state for womanhood, because the idea being promoted is that women are always vulnerable and at threat, no matter what their marital status or other circumstances.

iv) Private/corporate sector have increasing presence in the economic growth of the country and gender balance in these enterprises is crucial. More employment and skill development opportunities for women will be promoted and adhering to laws and regulations relating to women will be ensured through systematic gender sensitization exercises. Companies will be encouraged to reserve a certain percentage of their CSR as gender component.

In line with quotas and other such mechanisms, such measures can easily devolve to reducing competitiveness and meritocracy in industry and society.

7.6. Gender Budgeting i) The gender focal points, gender desks, Gender Budgeting Cells set up in Ministries, state government Departments, Panchayats and urban local bodies with the broad mandate covering coordination and awareness raising, will be strengthened to conduct in-house gender audit of requisite policies, programs and schemes as well as their institutional mechanisms to suggest and/or take remedial action….

Policy should instead be re-worded from ‘gender budgeting’ to ‘women’s budgeting’ because that’s the only focus of this section, and not about budgets for both male and female genders.  Surely there is no policy statement which says that remedial action will be taken if men were suffering in a particular area or budget, so to call it as gender budgeting is a serious misnomer.

READ:  Feedback on Draft National Child Protection Policy

 

7.7 vi) Conducting regular surveys on violence against women will not restrict to only information on prevalence of violence but also information regarding health consequences of violence including mental and physical consequences.

There is dire need to conduct right surveys which measure violence against women not in terms of cases registered (e.g. under PWDVA), but in terms of how many of these cases had violence proven (e.g. medically, in court order etc).  A focus on number of cases will only result in bureaucrats or NGOs – which benefit from higher number of cases – trying to report higher numbers, so they can justify their jobs and get monetary and non-monetary incentives.

Questions about this Article?

Ask in Telegram Group Men Rights India Q&A  (Also include link to this Article when you post question)

👉Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony

Related Posts

  1. Proposed private bill for 40% or more maintenance to abandoned wives

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Law Making

Comments

  1. Srikant says

    June 22, 2016 at 12:22 pm

    Hi Vivek, I am Prasanna (Srikant Shastri is my alternate Facebook account I created to avoid wife’s problems) Please re-add me to facebook group. Seems I am blocked for some mistake. I had also consulted you with my case once, do you remember?

    I love this website and missing part of group very much.

    Reply
    • videv says

      June 22, 2016 at 9:18 pm

      You have to reapply to facebook group again

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call Men Rights India numbers For 498A/406/Dowry Case/DV/Maintenance/child custody-visitation/abusive-wife/false cases, CALL volunteers' phone lines:

👉Kannada/ Hindi/ English: Call Sharath +919738010456
👉Free guidance (10-15 min)
👉Paid Guidance (For 30 min or more), click to pay

Join our WhatsApp/Facebook groups

Join Our Telegram Channel for FREE updates

Social

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Instagram

Search this website

Important/Must Read/Permanent Posts

  • How to assess your false case and marriage breakup probability
  • How to take action against police or magistrate for 498A arrest without following CrPC 41 41A?
  • Why Indian men should be very careful in filing divorce
  • What to do if CAW cell/police/advocate is putting pressure to compromise
  • Innocent until proven guilty is the law, use it!
  • Advice to men on 498a, maintenance, DV, divorce, child custody, what else
  • How to find and manage your lawyer in 498a, DV, CrPC 125, divorce, RCR cases
  • How to fight false cases of DV, Maintenance, CrPC 125, 498a etc
  • How to assess maintenance amount likely to be ordered in CrPC 125 or HMA 24
  • Notes and questions on court procedures
  • What should be my stand in court?
  • Understanding the divorce industry in India


Take Quizzes to test your legal knowledge!

Book: How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act


👉(Read Online eBook)👈
(Buy Print book)
(Buy Digital eBook)
(Information about the Book)

Contribute via UPI: videv@upi / videv@icici / videv@paytm

Today’s Popular Posts

  • How to fight false cases of DV, maintenance, CrPC…
  • How to file objections/written statement to…
  • Basic Cross-examination techniques in matrimonial…
  • Procedure of CAW (Crime against women) cell,…
  • Section 41, 41A, 41B of CrPC which govern arrest by…
  • Why Indian men should be very careful in filing divorce
  • Contact
  • How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125…
  • How to complain against judges of trial courts, High…
  • Using Purshis in court

Tags

498A Activism Arrest Child Support Child_Custody_Visitation Commando Gyan Commando Strategy Commando Techniques CrPC CrPC 125 Cruelty Divorce Domestic Violence Industry Dowry DV Act Judgments Evidence False Case False Rape Family Law Feminazis Feminist Figures Feminist Propaganda Fight Back HC Judgment Hindu Marriage Act HMA 24 Law Making Law Misuse Laws Legal Info live-in Maintenance Marriage Men Rights NCW NRI Police Press Release PWDVA(DV Act) Rape RTI SC Judgment Supreme Court WCD Women Reservation Bill

The Benefits of Reading Men Rights India!

before reading MRI
Before


after reading MRI
After

email: I am facing false DV case. I love your blog. It really have me boost to fight this case and I feel so happy that you guys are doing such a commendable work.


comment: Your survey is 100 % true. whatever is written in this blog matches more than 90 % of my marriage life situation.


comment: The Article is really great, it’s actually happening in my life. whatever is mentioned here is the tactics are used by my wife and still going on….


comment: This is a very good article, and some points mentioned here are the real reasons males are threatened to shell out the maintenance amount


comment: This document is very help for me,becoise i am sufring for false dowry case and fiting for them.so thank for to u.


comment: The web content is very useful for its diversity and especially for atrocities committed upon men, emitting a clarion call for them to rise and defend their rights and hood.


comment: Thanks you People doing very may allah grant you Success. Ameen.


comment: This is very helpful. Thanks a lot. Your work is really a morale booster..
Search judgments at Bharat Law
Read judgments at Bharat Law
IPC 498A Judgments
IPC 406 Judgments
DV Act Judgments
CrPC 125 Judgments
Child Custody Judgments

Author on Facebook

Vivek Deveshwar

Free eBook: Surviving the Legal Jungle

Surviving-the-Legal-Jungle-Cover-Image

Featured Posts

Congress and BJP MPs scuttle seat reservation for women

7 Apr 2010 By videv Leave a Comment

DV rules – Email version 1

15 Apr 2010 By videv 2 Comments

Powers of and procedure to be followed by CAW Cells – Important Delhi High Court judgments

5 Jul 2010 By videv 6 Comments

6 (not 10) excuses we wouldn’t want to hear from Preity Zinta

20 Jun 2014 By videv 4 Comments

How to file objections/written statement to wife’s DV/CrPC 125/divorce etc petition

13 Feb 2015 By videv 27 Comments

Equality for Men – Myth or Reality?

Download IMD handbook
Download IMD handbook

Recent Comments

  • videv on Advice to women on IPC 498a, DV case, maintenance, divorce etc.
  • Ankur on Mumbai Bandra Family court judgment on joint equally shared custody based on parenting plan
  • Khushi on Advice to women on IPC 498a, DV case, maintenance, divorce etc.
  • videv on Yodha Strategies and Techniques – YS101 course
  • videv on How to handle allegation of impotence by wife

RSS Feeds

  • All Posts
  • DV Act Judgments
  • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
  • 498A Judgments

Archives

Copyright © 2009-2021 · Vivek Deveshwar · Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Bare Acts
    • IPC 498A bare act
    • CrPC 125 Bare Act
    • The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – bare act
    • Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Bare Act
  • 498a
    • 498a Tips
    • 498a Info
    • 498a Judgments
  • DV Act
    • DV Act Tips
    • DV Act Info
    • DV Act Judgments
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
    • Maintenance HMA 24 Judgments
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Child Custody
    • Child Custody Visitation Judgments
    • Child Custody Visitation News
    • Free and Paid eBooks on Law Basics, Maintenance, Divorce, Child Custody, Alimony
  • Misc
    • Divorce Judgments
    • Law Misuse
    • Marriage
    • Misandry
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Important Posts