Men Rights India

  • Contact
  • Bare Acts
    • IPC 498A bare act
    • CrPC 125 Bare Act
    • The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – bare act
    • Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Bare Act
  • 498a
    • 498a Tips
    • 498a Info
    • 498a Judgments
  • DV Act
    • DV Act Tips
    • DV Act Info
    • DV Act Judgments
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
    • Maintenance HMA 24 Judgments
  • Child Custody
    • Child Custody Visitation Judgments
    • Child Custody Visitation News
  • Misc
    • Divorce Judgments
    • Law Misuse
    • Marriage
    • Misandry
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Important Posts
You are here: Home » Uncategorized » Delhi Mahila court denies maintenance to doctor wife from doctor husband

Delhi Mahila court denies maintenance to doctor wife from doctor husband

21 Mar 2015 By videv 3 Comments

Found this news full judgment of Nov 2014 about a maintenance judgment in a Mahila court in Delhi where maintenance was denied to a woman doctor earning 21,200 p.m.  I was aware of something called Mahila thana (women’s police station) which are supposed to make women feel comfortable to file complaint in front of women policepersons.  But don’t know what exactly is this phenomenon called Mahila court and the logic behind it, since delivery of justice and courts are something where everyone irrespective of gender, caste, religion will be received equally without prejudice!  So what is the logic behind Mahila court?  Will women get better justice, or real justice, or gender-sensitive justice there?  What exactly will they get in Mahila court which they can’t get in ‘ordinary’ court?  Anyway end of rant now.

👉(Read Online eBook): How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act 👈

👉(Read Online eBook): Alimony and Maintenance under Hindu Law👈

The judgment seems to be on solid footing citing Delhi HC precedents and sound logic based on facts of the case that wife too was a BDS, MBBS qualified doctor and actually she admitted to earning Rs 21,2000 per month.  Come on!  Spare the courts wastage of time in handling such cases.

Important part of judgment below:


7. In the case in hand also both husband and wife are equally

qualified doctors   having qualifications of BDS, MBBS etc and

admittedly complainant is earning an amount of Rs. 21,200/­ PM  at

present and she has also received an amount of Rs. 51000/­ from her

previous employer and as per income affidavit of respondent he was

employed on contract basis and his contract had already ended.

In these circumstances when complainant and respondents are

equally qualified and complainant herself is employed as well as in

view of aforesaid judgment, complainant is not entitled to any kind

of interim maintenance at this stage from the respondent / husband

and her application stands dismissed accordingly.

 


Full judgment text below:
Note: names of parties have been removed


CC No. 15/3

Complainant Wife vs Respondent Husband & Ors.

03.11.2014

Present: Ld. Counsel for complainant.

Respondent with Ld. Counsel.

1. Vide this order this court shall decide application for interim

maintenance moved on behalf of petitioner thereby demanding

interim maintenance to the tune of Rs. 50,000/­ per month from the

respondent / husband.

2. It is admitted fact that marriage between the complainant and

respondent no. 1 was solemnized on 11.05.2011 according to Hindu

rites and ceremonies at UP.  It is alleged by the complainant /wife

that parents of the complainant spent a lot on her marriage but

despite that respondent / husband was not happy with the dowry

brought by the complainant being insufficient and that is why

respondent caused extreme physical, mental, verbal, emotional and

economic torture to the complainant and at present complainant

and respondent are residing separately. On 07.10.11, complainant in

order to save her life took her all certificates, few clothings and

reached at her friends place at Ghaziabad but respondent / husband

contacted the complainant on phone and gave threat of dire

consequences and called up parents of the complainant and started

abusing them on 12.10.11.  On 25.10.11 complainant finally decided

to not to go back to

..2..

respondent no. 1 at matrimonial home and she decided to stay at

Delhi because of the threats and harassment caused by the

respondents.

3. During the course of arguments it is submitted on behalf of

complainant that she is claiming interim maintenance to the tune of

Rs. 50,000/­ PM from respondent / husband though she is employed

and earning an amount of Rs. 21,200/­ PM but the same is not

sufficient for her maintenance.   It is also submitted that respondent

is earning an amount of Rs. 1,40,000/­ PM as per his own income

affidavit.

4. On the other hand,  it is submitted on behalf of respondent in

his reply that complaint filed by the complainant is false and

frivolous and no dowry demand has ever been made by the

respondents.  It is further submitted that the car which was gifted by

the parents of the complainant had already been taken by the

complainant alongwith her.  It is also submitted that on 29.8.14

respondents contract got terminated and income of Rs. 1.40 lacs has

ended.  During the course of arguments it is also submitted that

complaint and respondent both are qualified Doctors and therefore

for the aforesaid reasons, complainant’s application for interim

maintenance be dismissed with cost.

5. I have heard the arguments addressed on behalf of both the

parties and perused the record carefully.

..3..

6. Perusal of income affidavit filed on behalf of complainant and

respondent no. 1 reveals that both are well qualified doctors as

complainant is having professional qualification of DDS and MBA

and respondent is having professional qualification of MBBS, M.Ph

and PGDE.    Delhi High court has categorically held in Judgment

titled  Sanjay Bhardwaj & Ors. Vs State & Anr, 2010 IV AD (CRL)

(DHC) 481 (HIGH COURT OF DELHI) CRL. M.C.NO. 491/2009

“We are living in an era of equality of sexes.  The constitution
provide equal treatment to be given irrespective of sex, caste
and  creed.  An unemployed husband, who is holding an MBA
decree, cannot be treated differently to an unemployed wife,
who is also holding an MBA decree.  Since both are on equal
putting one cannot be asked to maintain other unless one is
employed and other is not  employed. ”  Hon’ble High Court
further held that “no law provides that a husband has to
maintain a wife, living separately from him,  irrespective   of
the fact whether he earns or not.   Court cannot tell the
husband that he should beg, borrow or steal but give
maintenance to  the wife, more so when the husband and wife
are almost equally qualified and almost equally capable of
earning. ”
7. In the case in hand also both husband and wife are equally

qualified doctors   having qualifications of BDS, MBBS etc and

admittedly complainant is earning an amount of Rs. 21,200/­ PM  at

present and she has also received an amount of Rs. 51000/­ from her

previous employer and as per income affidavit of respondent he was

..4..

employed on contract basis and his contract had already ended.

In these circumstances when complainant and respondents are

equally qualified and complainant herself is employed as well as in

view of aforesaid judgment, complainant is not entitled to any kind

of interim maintenance at this stage from the respondent / husband

and her application stands dismissed accordingly.

8. Put up for CE on 06.01.2015.

(SHILPI JAIN)
MM (MAHILA COURT)
ROHINI/DELHI/03.11.14

 

READ:  What should be my stand in court?

Links to Free eBooks

1. Download my free PDF eBook Surviving the Legal Jungle

2. Read this FREE eBook written by fathers involved in child custody issues (Read Online) (PDF book)

3. How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act (Read Online)

Links to Paid eBooks/Books


1. How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act (Digital eBook) (Print Paperback)

2. Self-study Book on Divorce for Men (Digital eBook Only)

3. Alimony and Maintenance under Hindu Law (Digital eBook) (Print Paperback)

Related Posts

  1. Factors for increase in maintenance under CrPC 125 and CrPC 127
  2. SC Judgment on factors deciding quantum of maintenance under CrPC 125
  3. Wife denied maintenance under CrPC 125 since she had income earlier
  4. Judgment Delhi court:No maintenance to qualified wife under 24 HMA

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Maintenance

Comments

  1. Virat Agarwal says

    October 31, 2015 at 1:39 am

    The legend of the Barrackpore Court, 24 pgs (N), West Bengal.
    One female blackmailer/murderer married one guy to get money by blackmailing him. This is the way she wants to fulfill her parent’s dream, not by doing a prestigious job being a BTech engineer. Other hand that guy is become unemployed due to her untolerable mental torture. She already done false cases u/s maintenance (125 Cr.P.C) & 498A+34 IPC+3/4 D.P. act against him & told everyone she has done Divorce case against him. She do live-together with one person & money will be extract from another. She also carried all valuables (jewelry, important documents etc.) got from her matrimonial. I respect the ladies who live in red-light area & caring their family and hate this type of worst business mentality.
    She left her matrimonial of February, 2014 to attend her younger sister’s marriage ceremony & never came back. Without prior discussion/intimation after 9 months in the month of December, 2014 he got the intimation of case U/s-125 Cr.P.C from Ld. Judicial Magistrate, 5th court, Barrackpore. And after 1 year 3 months in the month of June, 2015 he got the intimation of U/s- 498(A)/34 IPC & 3/4 DP Act against him & his parents (both are senior citizen). He & his parents took bail for 498(A)/34 IPC & 3/4 DP Act on the first day & after that she never attend that case.
    At Barrackpore court (125 Cr.P.C, on February, 2015) the Judicial Magistrate, 5th court, Barrackpore passed the ad-interim order of maintenance as wish of her & he was so much pleased to pass the order. For hearing, both the parties were present & hearing done in 45 seconds. Not a single word used by her advocate & left the court room in 45 seconds with her. After one month in the month of March, 2015 the court order released of Rs.15,000/- per month maintenance for her, on the basis of her A F F I D A V I T. The family of that guy is lower middle class & he was the only earning member. He never earned more than Rs. 20,000/- per month in his life & at present he is unemployed.
    He filled a revisional application in High Court Calcutta which was moved before the Hon’ble Justice Joymalya Bagchi on June, 2015 challenging the ad-interim order of maintenance passed by the Judicial Magistrate, 5th court, Barrackpore and on which His Lordship has been pleased to direct to serve copy of the revisional application on the Ld. Public Prosecutor for the State and the opposite party.
    Again on the month of October, 2015 Judicial Magistrate of 5th court, Barrackpore passed arrest warrant for dues arrears (MEX case of Rs.45,000/-).
    (Important Note—- the date of due arrear hearing was changed without informing the male side, the hearing was done 4 days before the announced date. He came to know that arrest warrant already issued against him on the announced date of hearing).
    All the supporting documents (Btech certificate of her, previous employment doc of her, police report of 498A etc.) were submitted to the Judicial Magistrate, 5th court, Barrackpore.
    As per my view Barrackpore court (24 pgs N, West Bengal) is the business place. All the members of the court are dealing in the percentage of money in the name of demurrage of female.
    My earnest request to you all, please share your views on this.

    Reply
    • videv says

      November 2, 2015 at 8:25 pm

      You can join the groups and discuss there. Once you say wife is murderer or live-in with someone else than husband, better have some proof about it too… we are not into melodrama creation and plain rona dhona

      Reply
  2. Abhishek Shrivastava says

    April 11, 2015 at 10:48 pm

    Its very good design. But according to my point of view men and women both should be rights to do complaint.for hushband or wife tafter that police should be do investigation first and who is true man or women after that note down FIR and put cases according to their investigation result and after that court will decide a punishment for their crime.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call Men Rights India numbers For 498A/406/Dowry Case/DV/Maintenance/child custody-visitation/abusive-wife/false cases, CALL volunteers' phone lines (for quick guidance only):
(Be respectful to volunteers, & we don't advise on divorce)

1. Kannada/Hindi/English: +919738010456
2. Tamil/English: +919962514226

Join our WhatsApp/Facebook groups for FREE guidance/discussion

Join Our Telegram Channel for FREE updates

Social

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Instagram

Search this website

Important/Must Read/Permanent Posts

  • How to assess your false case and marriage breakup probability
  • How to take action against police or magistrate for 498A arrest without following CrPC 41 41A?
  • Why Indian men should be very careful in filing divorce
  • What to do if CAW cell/police/advocate is putting pressure to compromise
  • Innocent until proven guilty is the law, use it!
  • Advice to men on 498a, maintenance, DV, divorce, child custody, what else
  • How to find and manage your lawyer in 498a, DV, CrPC 125, divorce, RCR cases
  • How to fight false cases of DV, Maintenance, CrPC 125, 498a etc
  • How to assess maintenance amount likely to be ordered in CrPC 125 or HMA 24
  • Notes and questions on court procedures
  • What should be my stand in court?
  • Understanding the divorce industry in India

Book: How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance under CrPC 125 and DV Act


👉(Read Online eBook)👈
(Buy Print book)
(Buy Digital eBook)
(Information about the Book)

Today’s Popular Posts

  • Advice to women on IPC 498a, DV case, maintenance,…
  • How to complain against judges of trial courts, High…
  • How to file objections/written statement to…
  • Section 41, 41A, 41B of CrPC which govern arrest by…
  • Why Indian men should be very careful in filing divorce
  • How to handle allegation of impotence by wife
  • Basic Cross-examination techniques in matrimonial…
  • Procedure of CAW (Crime against women) cell
  • सीआरपीसी की धारा 41, 41 ए, 41 बी जिन में बिना वारंट…
  • About the book: How to Fight and Reduce Maintenance…

Tags

498A Activism Arrest Child Support Child_Custody_Visitation Commando Gyan Commando Strategy Commando Techniques CrPC CrPC 125 Cruelty Divorce Domestic Violence Industry Dowry DV Act Judgments Evidence False Case False Rape Family Law Feminazis Feminist Figures Feminist Propaganda Fight Back HC Judgment Hindu Marriage Act HMA 24 Law Making Law Misuse Laws Legal Info live-in Maintenance Marriage Men Rights NCW NRI Police Press Release PWDVA(DV Act) Rape RTI SC Judgment Supreme Court WCD Women Reservation Bill

The Benefits of Reading Men Rights India!

before reading MRI
Before


after reading MRI
After

email: I am facing false DV case. I love your blog. It really have me boost to fight this case and I feel so happy that you guys are doing such a commendable work.


comment: Your survey is 100 % true. whatever is written in this blog matches more than 90 % of my marriage life situation.


comment: The Article is really great, it’s actually happening in my life. whatever is mentioned here is the tactics are used by my wife and still going on….


comment: This is a very good article, and some points mentioned here are the real reasons males are threatened to shell out the maintenance amount


comment: This document is very help for me,becoise i am sufring for false dowry case and fiting for them.so thank for to u.


comment: The web content is very useful for its diversity and especially for atrocities committed upon men, emitting a clarion call for them to rise and defend their rights and hood.


comment: Thanks you People doing very may allah grant you Success. Ameen.


comment: This is very helpful. Thanks a lot. Your work is really a morale booster..
Search judgments at Bharat Law
Read judgments at Bharat Law
IPC 498A Judgments
IPC 406 Judgments
DV Act Judgments
CrPC 125 Judgments
Child Custody Judgments

Author on Facebook

Vivek Deveshwar

Free eBook: Surviving the Legal Jungle

Surviving-the-Legal-Jungle-Cover-Image

Featured Posts

Old couple blame misuse of dowry law for losing house

17 Apr 2010 By videv Leave a Comment

Why is NCPCR washing off its hands from Child Custody issues?

31 Mar 2020 By videv Leave a Comment

DV rules – Email version 1

15 Apr 2010 By videv 2 Comments

Court rejects sister’s application under PWDVA (DV Act)

20 Oct 2009 By videv 4 Comments

How to safeguard from false cases by wife–Part 1

15 Apr 2016 By videv 16 Comments

Equality for Men – Myth or Reality?

Download IMD handbook
Download IMD handbook

Recent Comments

  • videv on How to get Provident Fund (PF) details of wife
  • Raghu on How to get Provident Fund (PF) details of wife
  • videv on How to assess maintenance amount likely to be ordered in CrPC 125 or HMA 24
  • P2 on How to assess maintenance amount likely to be ordered in CrPC 125 or HMA 24
  • Child visitation monitor New Haven on Strategy for Child Custody for Men

RSS Feeds

  • All Posts
  • DV Act Judgments
  • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
  • 498A Judgments

Archives

Copyright © 2009-2021 · Vivek Deveshwar · Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Bare Acts
    • IPC 498A bare act
    • CrPC 125 Bare Act
    • The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – bare act
    • Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Bare Act
  • 498a
    • 498a Tips
    • 498a Info
    • 498a Judgments
  • DV Act
    • DV Act Tips
    • DV Act Info
    • DV Act Judgments
  • Maintenance
    • Maintenance CrPC 125 Judgments
    • Maintenance HMA 24 Judgments
  • Child Custody
    • Child Custody Visitation Judgments
    • Child Custody Visitation News
  • Misc
    • Divorce Judgments
    • Law Misuse
    • Marriage
    • Misandry
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Important Posts